Don’t Give It Away for Free!

So, what do you do when someone wants free advice?

I talked to someone the other day who had just hung out her freelance Web writing shingle. That means, she’s hustling for clients. All. The. Time.

She had a great sales-call conversation with a local business owner. They talked. They laughed. They bonded. He asked her, “What changes would you make to my site,” and she spent 45 minutes outlining how she’d change the Titles, how she’d start a blog, how she’d add keyphrases to his copy. She even showed him how to research keyphrases.

She was convinced she got the gig. The prospect told her that “He’d let her know” — and she hung up the call in a sales-happy daze.

Fast forward two weeks. The prospect won’t return her calls. He won’t return her emails. And when she looks at his site – surprise, surprise – some of the copy was changed per her suggestions.

Where did she go wrong?

She gave it away for free.

This is a problem for any professional. If you work with computers, everyone calls you for tech support. If you’re an attorney, people ask you to answer “Quick legal questions.” And if you’re a freelance SEO copywriter (or SEO professional) the question on everyone’s minds is, “How can I do better in Google?”

Don’t get me wrong – I’m all for educating prospects. That’s important. But there’s a fine line between educating clients on best practices and telling them how you’d “fix” their site (or whatever you get paid to do.)

This can be especially tricky during the sales process. You may really, really need this sale. Or, the person asks you face-to-face. Suddenly, not giving out free information seems like a sales (and social) faux pas. You start wondering if other people have given out freebie information and you’ll look bad if you don’t.  Heck, it doesn’t feel comfortable to say, “Uh, you have to pay me for that.”

No, it doesn’t feel comfortable. You don’t need to say those words, exactly…but you do need to say something like them. That is, if you want to make money.

Yes, you want to show off your expertise during the sales process. Yes, you want to wow the prospect. At the same time, you need to set a boundary. You need to know – clearly, deep in your heart-of-hearts know – that you are willing to talk about X for free. Maybe you provide one tip. Maybe you provide very general (but highly educational information.)

Or maybe, you don’t want to give anything away for free – even the most basic information. That’s OK, too.

When the prospect says something like, “What would you do to fix my site,” that’s when your boundary should kick in. Say what you’re comfortable saying and then steer back to the sales process. Tell them, “It looks like you have many Web writing opportunities here. I can outline them out in a report that contains (X) and costs (Y).

Or you could say, “That’s a great question. I’d have to dig deeper into your issues to really help you – let me tell you a bit more about how I consult with clients like you.”

You’re not ignoring their question or being rude. You’re simply – and nicely – informing them of your limits. At that point, they can choose to work with you (get the information they obviously want to have) or try to find someone who will give them freebie help. Either way, you win.

Consider if it’s time that you reviewed your own sales process. Have you felt “trapped” into providing “too much” information? Do you give it away for free? Are you gaining new clients – or inexplicably losing gigs? It could be that a slight change in your sales process can actually drive new business.

What about you? What kinds of information do you give away for free — or do you?

6 replies
  1. George Passwater says:

    Wow…this is a post every professional should read. I get these types of requests ALL THE TIME! I am in business to make money to feed my family, not give away free stuff and live on the street.

    Great advice on swinging the conversation to one of your services. I also work in how I can give them more information on a report or a certain package would address their site, but they are often say, “why can’t you just tell me?”

    Really? I am sorry, but it doesn’t say “free seo copywriting advice” on my forehead.

    • Heather says:


      LOL – you know, come to think of it, I’ve never seen “Will work for free” on your forehead either!

      Hearing, “Why can’t you tell me” is so frustrating (and so rude.) Then again, you can always reply, “Why can’t you pay me?” ;)

  2. Ryan Boots says:

    I think the best approach is to communicate the level of experience and knowledge in SEO that one brings to the table. When it comes to SEO in general, I let the client know that organic rankings are based on a combination of factors, only some of which are publicly known. I think it’s really most accurate to say that SEO is like a big puzzle. That alone tends to give the client the (correct) impression that SEO really is something they really can’t tackle alone and still run their business effectively.

    Along the same lines, I drill home my breadth of experience: I’ve blogged professionally for a nonprofit, written white papers, case studies, forum submissions, brochures, press releases and PPC ad copy. And I make it clear that, for webpage copy, I combine SEO best practice with my writing expertise. Similar to broad-based SEO, I try to impress upon the client that they simply don’t have the skill set, time or patience to craft the copy properly.

  3. Elaine Ellis says:

    I don’t freelance but a significant number of friends in PR and design make money that way. It always amazes me people expect them to do “quick projects” for free. It’s not even asking for free advice but free work.

    • Heather says:


      :Sigh:: You’re right. That happens all the time. What’s worse, folks like that don’t understand how anyone could say no to such a “reasonable request.” :)

      How do your friends handle it when it happens to them?

  4. craig wright says:

    Most of the SEO info is out there on the web for FREE. If people look for it, they will find it easy enough. What is more difficult to find is the copywriting skill to judge the target market, get the right angle and pitch the content at the right level.

    When I’m giving a quote, I’m pretty vague on the copywriting aspects, but a bit more open about what I will do for their headings, titles, etc. I always emphasise the importance of getting the copy to appeal to prospects, not just Google and that that is where the true skill lies.

    People may be able to fix the SEO in the same way that you would have, but they won’t find tackling the actual writing quite so easy.

    Works for me (most of the time).


Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.